Composite Radial Progress Demo (source) is a user experience idea I’ve had for years that I thought would be worth investigating. With the “modern gen” games 1 filled to the brim with radial progress bars now, I decided to build a quick prototype of this variant and finally get the idea out of my head and onto some form of example. Particularly because this is the sort of “hula hoop” idea that if you sketch it on paper people laugh at it, but seeing it in action might give a few insights into it.
History of the Idea
A long time ago in that teenage place where every young programmer thinks they should build their own operating system 2 I thought it would be really cool if an operating system offered a progress bar summary of all active progress bars. I spent too much time thinking about how you would build such a progress bar without violating some basic user experience courtesies of a progress bar. The primary courtesy being the one of “forward momentum”: a linear progress bar expands left-to-right and if it goes backwards (right-to-left) it was 3 typically meant to indicate some sort of error or fallback. The obvious solution to me at the time was that a radial progress bar/wheel could easily keep forward momentum (clockwise movement of the head) while also allow for the tail to catch up when new tasks are added.
I thought it would be neat to have a radial progress bar summary translucently spinning around the mouse cursor, like the mouse-attached HUD in some video games.
Possible Use Cases
In addition to the aforementioned idea of an OS presenting a “progress HUD”, I’ve kept the idea under my hat in case it came in handy for a game design somewhere, eventually.
The obvious use case in today’s world where someone sees a lot of progress bar and new ones could show up and any moment is the downloads window of most web browsers.
In programming there are often many cases where a recursive algorithm is handy and each task may have an unknown number of subtasks once you start on that task. This is also the sort of user experience where I think this composite radial progress bar is superior to a normal flat progress bar that either ends up “stuck” or “moving backwards” as sub-tasks are discovered. Also, a gentle spin on the bar as a whole makes the bar it’s own “indeterminate” state and never gives a truly “stuck/frozen/crashed” impression, even if the completion percentage isn’t changing.
A Modern Aesthetic
Radial progress bars are cool and hip and filling so much of our 1080p screen space in video games right now. I’m almost surprised that a game hasn’t done a loading bar or something similar already even remotely like my little prototype here.
Even Tetris Ultimate is filled with radial progress wheels. Tetris! It’s a game comprised of blocks and the UI is full of circles and arcs now! ↩
It may not be “every” programmer, but it certainly seems a large percentage. I’m fairly convinced that this is place where a lot of Unix distributions come from, for instance. ↩
Times change expectations: It’s quite a bit more common these days to see backwards momentum in progress bars and not surprise the users that something might be wrong. ↩